Senate panel advances top DOJ Civil Rights Division lawyer’s judicial nomination

Prefer us on Google

to see more of our voting rights news coverage when you search.

A plaque commemorating the founding of the Department of Justice Civil Rights Division is displayed on a bookshelf in a Civil Rights Division conference room at Department of Justice headquarters in Washington, D.C. on April 1, 2026. (Francis Chung/POLITICO via AP Images)

The Senate Judiciary Committee advanced Jesus Osete’s nomination to the federal bench Tuesday, bringing the controversial second-in-command at the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) Civil Rights Division a step closer to a lifetime appointment.

The committee voted 12-10 down party lines to move Osete’s nomination to the Senate floor.  

President Donald Trump nominated Osete for the Western District of Missouri in August, praising his work as the Civil Rights Division’s principal deputy assistant attorney general. As former Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon’s chief lieutenant, Osete played a central role in the DOJ’s assault on voting rights — a ham-fisted effort marked by glaring errors that mostly failed as federal judges repeatedly ruled against the government. 

After taking a drubbing in the midterm elections and losing control of the Senate, Republicans are sprinting to confirm as many of President Donald Trump’s nominees as possible during the lame duck session. Judiciary Chairman Charles Grassley (R-Iowa) tacked the nominations vote onto a previously-scheduled hearing in violation of the committee’s rules, Democratic ranking member Dick Durbin (Ill.) complained. 

Ahead of the vote on his candidacy, Durbin excoriated Osete for his tenure at the Civil Rights Division, which has lost roughly 70% of its lawyers since he joined. 

“Even among the unqualified and inexperienced nominees put forward by the president, Mr. Osete stands out. Over the course of his career, he has attacked voting rights, reproductive rights, [and] LGBTQ rights,” Durbin said. “Since last year, he has served as a senior political appointee in the Civil Rights Division, known as the crown jewel of the Justice Department. During Mr. Osete’s tenure, the Trump administration has decimated this division.”

Before the DOJ, Osete worked in private practice and in Missouri’s attorney general’s office under now-Sen. Eric Schmitt (R-Mo.). He also served as general counsel to Missouri’s secretary of state.

Osete is a prolific social media poster, much like his former boss at the DOJ, Dhillon. Amid the Civil Rights Division’s attempt to sue states into handing over unredacted voter registration records, during which the DOJ racked up an 0-28 record in federal district court, Osete frequently sparred on X with state officials who opposed that effort. He also tried to highlight the upside of some humiliating appellate losses by posting about judicial dissents.

Osete graduated from Washington University in St. Louis School of Law in 2016. As a student, he wrote an essay that argued the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Shelby County v. Holder, which significantly weakened the Voting Rights Act (VRA), had led directly to incidents of voter suppression.

“It is of no coincidence that these events are occurring today. We frequently see other examples of post-Shelby County repercussions in legislation calling for strict voter ID requirements that effectively cause disparate treatment among certain groups of people,” Osete wrote. “The justifications being put forward are that of cost-efficiency and fraud prevention, which both likely serve as pretexts for discriminatory actions against minorities regardless of the racially neutral nature of the measures.”

But Osete went on to champion those policies in Missouri and at the DOJ, where he helped write the government’s amicus brief in Louisiana v. Callais, which successfully urged the Court to further eviscerate the VRA. 

During his confirmation hearing in October, Osete said his experience litigating “various cases where I’ve defended common sense voter ID laws and many other election integrity measures to combat fraud” led him to change his position.

Osete also led the DOJ’s unsuccessful effort to block California’s mid-decade redistricting, which the state launched in response to the Trump-led wave of Republican states adopting new congressional maps last year. 

Beyond voting rights issues, Osete has championed the administration’s anti-diversity initiatives and attacks on gun control measures.

If Osete’s nomination is confirmed by the full Senate, the 35-year-old will have a lifetime judicial appointment.

Besides Osete, the Senate Judiciary Committee also advanced the nominations of Robert Long for the Middle District of Florida and Peter Mansfield for the Eastern District of Louisiana. Long, a state judge in Florida who wrote an aggressive concurrence in a 2023 decision that eliminated a majority-Black congressional district, also advanced on a 12-10 vote.

Mansfield, a longtime DOJ prosecutor, advanced on a 14-8 vote.