Ohio Supreme Court orders some ballots to remain uncounted following GOP challenge

Prefer us on Google

to see more of our voting rights news coverage when you search.

A voter fills out a ballot, Nov. 5, 2024, in Catawba, Ohio. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

In a blow to voters, the Ohio Supreme Court granted a GOP state House candidate’s request to hold off counting some provisional ballots, as the deadline to certify the Buckeye State’s election looms.

Republican candidate Edward Schimmel challenged an unknown number of ballots in Lucas County, which will remain “sealed, unopened, and uncounted,” pending the court’s decision, Chief Justice Sharon Kennedy wrote in the Thursday order.

The Republican vying for Ohio’s 44th House District seat sued Monday — two weeks after the election — arguing some of those challenged provisional ballots were improperly cast by voters who had moved from one Ohio county to another without updating their addresses before the midterm election.

Schimmel asked the court to segregate and preserve the challenged provisional ballots, essentially seeking to block the votes from counting. 

Schimmel claimed those voters should have gone to a board of elections office instead of their polling place. Thousands of provisional ballots have already been processed and counted, the Lucas County Board of Elections said in its response, arguing Schimmel’s suit is now moot.

Voting rights groups on Wednesday pointed out that August guidance from Republican Secretary of State Frank LaRose directed election officials to allow people who have moved to another county within the state to cast a ballot in person, even if they didn’t update their address before Election Day.

The pro-voting organizations argue voters should not be disenfranchised because they followed guidance from the state’s chief election official and state election law. Democratic candidate David Fournier* is also asking to join the suit to argue it should be thrown out.

Schimmel is leading his Democratic opponent by only 33 votes, as of the latest counts. It’s unclear how many votes are impacted by Thursday’s court order, but provisional ballots have proven significant in determining the outcomes of close races in state elections.

*Elias Law Group (ELG) represents Democratic candidate David Fournier in his motion to intervene. ELG Chair Marc Elias is the founder of Democracy Docket.