Trump DOJ taps prosecutor behind failed California ballot lawsuit for Mar-a-Lago revenge probe
to see more of our voting rights news coverage when you search.
The Trump administration tapped Bill Essayli, the federal prosecutor who led its failed attempt to block thousands of California ballots from being counted, to investigate the FBI’s 2022 search of President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago residence.
The assignment comes just days after a federal judge refused to delay a ruling that found Essayli was unlawfully exercising the powers of Los Angeles’ top federal prosecutor.
Get updates straight to your inbox — for free
Join 350,000 readers who rely on our daily and weekly newsletters for the latest in voting, elections and democracy.
Essayli will oversee a key part of the Department of Justice’s sprawling investigation into whether federal law enforcement officials illegally targeted Trump during previous investigations.
The inquiry will focus on whether FBI agents and federal prosecutors broke the law when they searched Trump’s Florida residence in August 2022 as part of an investigation into his retention of classified documents.
The search, authorized by a federal judge, eventually led to criminal charges against Trump for allegedly mishandling classified documents and obstructing efforts to recover them. The case was later dismissed.
Essayli’s new assignment comes amid mounting questions about his own authority to oversee federal prosecutions.
In October, U.S. District Judge Michael Seabright ruled that Essayli had been unlawfully exercising the powers of an acting U.S. attorney beyond the statutory limit for temporary appointments. The judge ordered him disqualified from participating in or supervising two criminal prosecutions.
On Monday, Seabright rejected DOJ’s request to pause the disqualification while the department appeals. The order is scheduled to take effect November 23 unless an appeals court intervenes.
The ruling does not automatically prohibit Essayli from serving in other prosecutorial capacities. DOJ is assigning him to the Florida investigation as a special assistant U.S. attorney, while he remains first assistant U.S. attorney in Los Angeles.
Essayli has already played a prominent role in the Trump administration’s efforts to exert federal control over California’s elections.
Just weeks before the November midterms, his office sued California election officials in an attempt to prevent them from counting mail ballots associated with approximately 20,000 registered voters whom DOJ alleged were likely noncitizens.
Essayli personally argued the case in federal court, claiming that California risked illegally counting ballots cast by ineligible voters.
But state and county officials challenged the federal government’s claims, and Los Angeles County’s review of a sample of the flagged registrations found that many were already canceled or inactive.
U.S. District Judge David Carter rejected DOJ’s emergency request, warning that the sweeping intervention could disrupt an ongoing election and potentially discard ballots cast by eligible American citizens.
The Ninth Circuit also rejected the administration’s requests for emergency relief, and the Supreme Court declined to intervene before Election Day.
Essayli also publicly warned California election officials that knowingly processing ballots cast by noncitizens could expose them to criminal prosecution. Carter subsequently urged federal officials to stop threatening election workers.
After exhausting its emergency appeals, DOJ moved to dismiss the underlying lawsuit, acknowledging that the relief it sought was no longer possible after Election Day. The department moved to abandon its remaining appeal Tuesday.
The failed ballot challenge was part of the administration’s broader campaign to scrutinize voter rolls and challenge the eligibility of registered voters ahead of the midterms.
Essayli’s new assignment places him at the center of another politically charged DOJ investigation.
The broader inquiry, sometimes called the “grand conspiracy” investigation, has examined allegations that former federal officials coordinated to improperly investigate Trump over the past decade.
But the effort has struggled to develop evidence supporting that sweeping theory. Several prosecutors have left or been removed from the investigation, while DOJ has increasingly pursued narrower allegations involving specific investigations of Trump.
Essayli’s assignment follows the departure of Jason Reding Quiñones, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Florida who had been overseeing the broader inquiry.