A plan to sidestep the Electoral College may fail in court. Should Democrats go for it anyway?
to see more of our voting rights news coverage when you search.
After twenty years of plodding progress, a movement to sidestep the Electoral College and award the presidency to whoever wins the most votes nationally now stands at the finish line following multiple Democratic state house victories in the midterm elections.
And while the effort could still topple over the considerable legal hurdles ahead, backers say the plan’s political impact would only improve the odds of passing other electoral overhaul proposals.
If enacted, the National Popular Vote (NPV) Interstate Compact would prevent presidential elections like 2000 and 2016, when George W. Bush and Donald Trump respectively won despite receiving fewer votes than their Democratic opponents.
States join the compact by enacting laws that pledge their electoral votes to the candidate who wins the popular vote nationally, regardless of what the vote count is in the state. But those state laws only come into effect once enough states sign on to clear an absolute majority of 270 electoral votes. So far, 18 states and Washington, D.C. — a combined 222 electoral votes — have joined the compact.
This year, Democrats gained trifectas in six states, including five that aren’t yet compact members: Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. If those states join with their combined 61 electoral votes, it would bring the compact’s total to 283 and trigger the plan. And if they do that by July 20, 2028, the compact would be in effect for the next presidential election.
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro (D) and Wisconsin Gov.-elect David Crowley (D) have already said they support the plan.
It’s also broadly popular with voters. A new poll from Data for Progress, shared exclusively with Democracy Docket, found that 62% of likely voters think the national popular vote winner should get the White House, while just 31% prefer letting the Electoral College decide (7% said they didn’t know). That figure includes 76% of Democrats, 60% of independents and a plurality of Republicans (47% support the popular vote, while 45% back the Electoral College).
Those findings are consistent with surveys by the Pew Research Center, which has repeatedly found over the past two decades that roughly 60% of Americans prefer the popular vote over the Electoral College — with the exception of a dip after 2016 thanks to Republicans happy with Trump’s victory.
Despite the support from a sizable number of Republican voters, GOP officials mostly oppose NPV. In fact, the movement has been so dominated by Democrats that Akhil Reed Amar, the Yale University law professor who can credibly claim to have come up with the idea, now worries attempting to enact it might lead to a constitutional crisis.
Patrick Rosenstiel — a GOP political operative who helped whip up support for John Roberts’ and Samuel Alito’s appointments to the U.S. Supreme Court — dismissed those fears, saying voters all over will cheer the Electoral College’s demise.
Get updates straight to your inbox — for free
Join 350,000 readers who rely on our daily and weekly newsletters for the latest in voting, elections and democracy.
Besides, Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to the NPV campaign, thinks his fellow Republicans are wrong to fear the electoral fallout. NPV will force presidential candidates to campaign everywhere, rather than skipping from one battleground state to another, he said.
“We believe that every voter, in every precinct, in every state should be politically relevant — equally relevant — in presidential elections,” he said, noting that voter turnout in 2024 was 11% higher in swing states. “And we want to put voters back in charge of presidential elections, not courts in battleground states — through hair-splitting lawsuits — determining who wins or loses these pretty important elections.”
Rosenstiel isn’t celebrating yet, but he’s “never been more confident” the compact can be in place for 2028.
Legal challenges ahead
Once the compact goes live, it will undoubtedly face lawsuits from conservative groups challenging its constitutionality. After all, the Electoral College gives Republican-leaning states with small populations disproportionate sway over presidential elections.
Law professors have already detailed the constitutional issues that could derail the Compact, chief among them the question of whether it would require congressional consent or not.
Academics are entitled to their opinions, Rosenstiel said, but ultimately they don’t matter — the legal battle will be fought in the courts and won’t be over until the Supreme Court has its say. And he’s confident that this Court, based on the case law and the majority’s conservative leanings, would uphold the NPV and the interstate compact.
“Whether I believe it, you believe it, pick your favorite Harvard Law professor agrees with it – is irrelevant,” Rosenstiel said. “What they decide is relevant.”
That confidence could be misplaced: Critics frequently decry the Court’s inconsistency, particularly around election law. But Rosenstiel points to a series of essentially unanimous decisions going back more than a century interpreting the Constitution’s Presidential Electors Clause favorably.
Lawyers who question that, Rosenstiel said, “should not be sources in any of these stories because they don’t understand interstate compacts, and none of them have any idea what compacts require congressional consent or don’t based on current case law.”
But even if the Supreme Court does say that the interstate compact requires congressional approval, with Democrats in control of both chambers, NPV will simply go get it. And that, Rosenstiel argued, would only require a concurrent resolution, which isn’t subject to a president’s veto power. (And if the Court required a statute, Rosenstiel thinks there’s a good chance Trump, who once called the Electoral College a “disaster,” might sign it.)
The NPV doubters, however, raise many other legal concerns, and, as Notre Dame Law Professor Derek Muller recently noted, “supporters of the NPV have to win every one of these legal arguments for the Compact to take effect.”
The Presidential Electors Clause broadly reads that “Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors.” Some have argued that the Framers — who considered and then rejected the idea of direct popular presidential elections — did not intend Art. II, Sec. 1 to provide a loophole around the Electoral College that empowers a state to appoint electors based on the preferences of other states’ voters.
Muller has also noted that the Compact could run into problems with the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause and member states’ own constitutions, some of which have provisions that would arguably prevent state legislatures from adopting an electoral vote allocation scheme that relies, at least in part, on what out-of-state voters do.
Rosenstiel dismissed those arguments, saying NPV’s own lawyers have already carefully considered all those concerns and more over the past two decades the Compact plan has been in motion.
“There isn’t anybody who I find credible who believes that Michigan cannot award her electoral votes on the basis of a national popular vote,” he said.
NPV’s best legal argument may come, ironically, from a case that led to a popular vote loser winning the White House: Bush v. Gore. “The individual citizen has no federal constitutional right to vote for electors for the President of the United States unless and until the state legislature chooses a statewide election as the means to implement its power to appoint members of the Electoral College,” the per curiam majority wrote.
But even if the Supreme Court did ultimately reject the Compact, that doesn’t mean it wouldn’t have a huge impact on the political landscape.
Supreme Court v. Court of Public Opinion
Backing the Compact is a political no-brainer for Democrats, said Data for Progress Executive Director Ryan O’Donnell.
“Democrats should use all the power they’ve gained to demand changes to the way our political system empowers corruption, including ending partisan gerrymandering and passing new congressional ethics rules,” O’Donnell said. “If Republicans in Congress or President Trump want to be seen as blocking these popular reforms, they can explain that to voters in 2028.”
Adam Bozzi, a Democratic strategist at Anticipate Public Affairs who has worked on electoral reform proposals on Capitol Hill, agreed. Even if the NPV ultimately fails in the courts, he said, “having more scrutiny on the Electoral College is a good thing.”
“The more people learn about how the Electoral College really works and what it really does, helps us move towards a better system for electing a president, [and] then also helps us clarify in people’s mind that we need more changes to make the system work better for regular people,” Bozzi added.
The Supreme Court striking down another popular policy would also add fuel to the fire for reforming the high bench.
“The Supreme Court is already seen as a political institution. Voters are already concerned about the Court being biased towards conservative causes, and confidence in the Court is at historic lows,” said O’Donnell. “If it strikes down a plan to elect the president via the popular vote, that would only further undermine trust in the Court.”
Simply waging the legislative and legal fights would help Democrats improve their standing with voters, who “still see the party as weak and ineffective,” O’Donnell noted. “Voters want to see their leaders fight against a political system that answers to the powerful instead of the people, whether that means making every vote count equally or holding the Court to real ethics standards.”
That’s backed up by exit polling that showed that 33% of voters ranked the “state of democracy” as the most important issue facing the nation, second only to the economy (39%). Other surveys show voters overwhelmingly support efforts to curb government corruption.
Data for Progress’s latest poll also found broad support for electoral and lawmaking reforms, with 63% backing proposals to take redistricting out of the hands of state legislatures and require independent, nonpartisan redistricting commissions to redraw congressional maps going forward. That includes majorities of Democrats (68%), independents (69%) and Republicans (54%).
Some likely 2028 presidential candidates have signaled they support scrapping or reforming the Electoral College, including Shapiro and former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg. Speaking to reporters in D.C. earlier this week, Gov. Gavin Newsom (D-Calif.) urged his Democratic colleagues to go after the Electoral College, saying that “any election, nationally, should be a national election.”
Last time Democrats controlled the House, they passed two major electoral bills: the John R. Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act, which would restore the pre-clearance provisions of the Voting Rights Act (VRA) struck down by the Supreme Court, and the For the People Act, a broad package of reforms that would end gerrymandering, expand mail voting, impose ethics requirements on the Supreme Court, require more campaign finance disclosures and require presidential candidates to report ten years of tax returns.
The Voting Rights Advancement Act’s sponsor, Rep. Terri Sewell (D-Ala.), intends to reintroduce a beefed-up version of the legislation that would also try to remedy the Supreme Court’s evisceration of the VRA’s Section 2, which bans racial discrimination in voting.
When the final necessary state signs onto the Compact to push it over the 270 electoral vote threshold, Bozzi said, it will be the biggest story in the nation, dominating the news cycle for weeks as pundits debate the impact on the 2028 presidential election and NPV’s chances in the courts. And that would drive a national dialogue about democracy itself.
“The more attention we have on these matters, and the more Americans are looking at a broken system — and there’s a desire to fix it — that helps build momentum to get a broader set of reforms done,” he said.
And that might be enough to convince a handful of Republicans in the Senate to sit down at the negotiating table with Democrats on other, less dramatic electoral reforms.
“As a leverage point, it’s one more area where you can look at something to get done and potentially bring Republicans to the table,” Bozzi said. “This is an area where voters understand that the corruption impacts their own personal finances and their ability to afford their daily lives. That helps us make the case that we need strong, robust, bold democracy reforms.”