Ohio Lucas County Provisional Ballots Challenge
Schimmel v. Lucas County Board of Elections
An anti-voting lawsuit seeking to block election officials from counting an entire category of provisional ballots cast by registered Ohio voters.
Background
Edward Schimmel, a Republican candidate for Ohio’s House of Representatives, sued the Lucas County Board of Elections, seeking to eliminate all provisional ballots cast in the county by voters who recently moved from outside the county but did not update their address before Election Day. Schimmel contends that a directive from the Ohio Secretary of State to local poll-workers is invalid under Ohio law. The directive allows voters who have moved counties within Ohio but did not update their address before Nov. 3 to cast a provisional ballot at their new polling place on Election Day. Schimmel asserts the directive violates state law and he now asks the court to order that these provisional ballots be set aside, despite two weeks having passed since the 2026 midterms.
Why It Matters
This lawsuit risks disenfranchising qualified Ohio voters who simply relied on poll workers’ and the Ohio secretary of state’s guidance to cast their ballots. To set aside those ballots would leave these otherwise qualified voters with no recourse to have their voices heard.
Latest Updates
- Nov. 19, 2026: Schimmel filed a response to the judgment on the pleadings and the motion to dismiss.
- Nov. 18, 2026: Defendants filed an answer and filed a motion for judgment on the pleadings. David Fournier, Schimmel’s Democratic opponent, filed a motion to intervene as a defendant and filed a motion to dismiss. The League of Women Voters of Ohio and Common Cause filed an amicus brief.
- Nov. 16, 2026: Plaintiff filed its complaint.