Alaska’s real spoiler wasn’t Dan Sullivan. And he helped the GOP

Prefer us on Google

to see more of our voting rights news coverage when you search.

Voters cast ballots at Midtown Mall in Anchorage, Alaska, on Nov. 1, 2026. Photo by Christian Moorman / Hans Lucas / AFP via Getty Images)
Voters cast ballots at Midtown Mall in Anchorage, Alaska, on Nov. 1, 2026. Photo by Christian Moorman / Hans Lucas / AFP via Getty Images)

Juneau, Alaska – For weeks, President Donald Trump and his allies have desperately claimed that the presence of two Dan Sullivans on the ballot undermined the integrity of Alaska’s Senate race*. 

But in the end, it was a different Alaska contest that was disrupted by a spoiler candidate — to the benefit of the GOP.

Alaska’s election for its lone U.S. House seat went to ranked-choice tabulation on Wednesday night after no one reached the 50% threshold for first-choice votes.

Rep. Nick Begich (R) ultimately emerged victorious in the final round with 51.35% of the vote, defeating independent Bill Hill.

Hill was backed by Democrats as voters largely shunned Eric Hafner, who identified as a Democrat on the ballot. Hafner is currently serving a 20-year prison sentence in New York and has reportedly never been to Alaska, making him ineligible to serve under the U.S. Constitution.

Still, Hafner got 8% of first-choice votes. His 22,715 votes were more than the difference between Begich and Hill. 

State Sen. Bill Wielechowski, an Anchorage Democrat, said Democrats across the state received text messages from an unknown sender urging them to support Hafner. To counteract that, Wielechowski said a “significant amount of resources [and] funds were spent to inform Alaskans that, in fact, Eric Hafner is a convicted felon.”

Hafner was likely boosted by the national blue wave, Wielechowski said, which hurt Hill. 

When Hafner was eliminated in ranked-choice tabulation, more than half of his voters’ ballots (11,465) were “exhausted” – meaning they didn’t pick either Hill or Begich as their second choice.

Meanwhile, in the U.S. Senate race, Democrat Mary Peltola won more votes than the three other candidates combined. The second Dan Sullivan, who Republicans said would confuse voters and siphon off votes from Sen. Dan Sullivan (R), only received 4,765 votes — less than half the margin of Peltola’s victory over the GOP incumbent.

Yet, Trump and the Department of Justice are still pressing forward with a lawsuit seeking to block certification of Peltola’s win because of the two Sullivans issue, appealing a federal judge’s dismissal of the suit. Gov. Mike Dunleavy has said the state, too, is investigating.

The DOJ has also said its criminal probe into claims that Peltola’s campaign helped recruit the second Dan Sullivan is continuing — though “ballot stacking” is not illegal or uncommon. 

Laura Norton-Cruz, a voter in Anchorage, told Democracy Docket earlier this week that the Hafner race concerned her more than the Sullivans.

“It was abundantly clear which Dan Sullivan was which,” Norton-Cruz said. “What was a lot less clear to Alaskans was Eric Hafner being the only Democrat on the ballot in the House race because a pretty significant number of Alaskans voted for him not knowing that he is in federal prison in New York and has never been to Alaska.”

Wielechowski agreed.

“There obviously were a lot of people who were furious at the Republicans this year and just voted straight party-line ticket and they didn’t know, and they just voted for the Democrat on the ballot,” he said. 

“Hopefully, there’s going to be an investigation into that,” Wielechowski added. “I don’t know why the Trump administration or [Gov. Mike] Dunleavy’s administration are not investigating that because that’s equally as bad as they claim what’s happening in the Senate race.”

*The Elias Law Group (ELG) represents the Peltola campaign. ELG Firm Chair Marc Elias is the founder of Democracy Docket.