The growing constitutional crisis

Prefer us on Google

to see more of our voting rights news coverage when you search.

We’re keeping the paywall down a little longer. Marc’s premium analysis is free while the post-election fights play out. Start reading, and become a member to keep it coming.


The United States is in the midst of a constitutional crisis. I do not make this claim lightly or with any intended hyperbole. I am saying it now because too few are willing to speak out. If we fail to recognize it for what it is, it will only get worse.

Despite what we want to believe about what is “normal,” for the last decade, United States elections have been held hostage. We live under threat that one major party will not accept the results. 

The president uses his power to target vote counting and certification. He deploys federal prosecutors to intimidate opposition figures.

If this were another country, would we not agree that it faces a constitutional crisis? Would we say the crisis is over because the sitting president and his party failed in their efforts to subvert the midterm elections?

I understand that mine is not a popular opinion.

Free this week only Keep reading Marc’s analysis

Election Day has passed, but the fight hasn’t ended. Marc’s full analysis stays open for an extended time. Join now so you don’t lose access when the paywall goes back up.

Those on the right want to act as if Donald Trump’s actions have been justified all along. Many on the left want to celebrate the midterms as if the threat has been defeated. Much of the legacy media sees its role as questioning whether the crisis ever existed at all.

To be clear, litigating election rules and contesting election results does not by itself create a constitutional crisis.

A constitutional crisis occurs when those who hold power systematically weaponize the machinery of government against the very institutions the Constitution relies on to check that power. At a minimum, those checks include free and fair elections, equal treatment under the law and respect for democratic outcomes.

This is an intentionally narrow definition. Even after Jan. 6, 2021, I did not view the 2020 election as a crisis of constitutional dimensions.

As despicable as his actions were, Trump was acting largely as a defeated candidate. The scores of lawsuits filed by him and his allies relied on private resources. When he pressed the Department of Justice to intervene, its leadership refused.

In the end, the federal government did not become an instrument for altering the results. Trump considered a draft executive order in December 2020 that would have directed the Pentagon to seize voting machines, but he ultimately did not sign it.

The threats to the 2026 midterms were far more serious, because this time the government itself was the instrument.

It was the DOJ, not GOP campaigns, that tried to coerce states to turn over their sensitive voter data. It was by executive orders that Trump tried to tamper with state voting laws and weaponize the U.S. Postal Service. It was at the president’s direction that the DOJ tried to block the certification of a Democrat in the Alaska Senate race.

Most troubling has been the increased abuse of criminal law to threaten election officials and political opponents. These tactics began before the election. It was the FBI, under Kash Patel, that seized Fulton County, Georgia’s 2020 ballots and election records in January 2026.

But they have continued and escalated ever since.

I know this firsthand. I have spent my career representing Democrats in election litigation. That work has resulted in handing scores of defeats to Trump and Republicans in cases involving close elections.

In 2020, I helped lead the litigation to defeat Trump and his allies more than 60 times. In the run-up to this election, my law firm defeated Trump’s DOJ more than 30 times in court.

Only days before Election Day, it was revealed that Trump’s DOJ considered me a target of a criminal probe involving the Alaska Senate race. That designation came notwithstanding the U.S. Attorney saying that he wasn’t certain if there was any crime committed by anyone.

That did not matter to Trump. In the days that followed, the president repeatedly said on national television and on social media that I should go to jail.

After initially saying he would accept the results, Trump backtracked and suggested they were rigged.

When congressional Democrats made clear they would conduct oversight, Trump announced he was ordering the Justice Department to look into it. His White House counsel then warned that their investigative plans could cross into criminal behavior.

Critics of my argument will point out that no 2026 ballots were seized, no federal law enforcement appeared at the polls and Democrats won resounding victories. They will note that those results are being certified at the state level, and there is no indication that the peaceful transfer of power in Congress on Jan. 3, 2027, will not take place.

Above all, they will point out that the courts largely reined in the president’s actions and that their orders were followed.

Such a myopic view confuses Trump’s actions with the election results. Voters can overcome an abuse of power, but that does not make it any less an abuse.

With the help of the courts, voters may have defeated the attacks on our elections, but that does not diminish the attacks’ significance. And these claims ignore what is continuing to happen.

A bank teller who foils a robbery is still the victim of a crime. And if more robberies continue to occur at other banks, the spree has not ended.

The question is not whether Trump’s efforts succeeded. It is whether the executive branch went along with them and continues to do so.

Some pundits will say that I am raising a false alarm, that all of this shows how strong our elections are and that the system of protecting against government abuses has worked. But this misses the point.

Courts are imperfect protectors of democracy. They can block only what has already been attempted, and only after someone sues. A system that survives only by winning dozens of emergency lawsuits or by the falsely accused being exonerated at trial is neither healthy nor sustainable.

Now that voters have handed Congress to the Democrats, we are seeing an escalation of, not a retreat from, Trump’s attacks on the Constitution. His administration is systematically targeting congressional oversight.

Perhaps Democratic officials will remain strong in the face of these threats. Will the same be true of the staff and witnesses who make oversight possible?

I have grown accustomed to being targeted by Trump. But how many other lawyers will shy away from taking on the administration if the threat of prosecution is the cost of doing the work?

If all of this were happening in another country, we would know what to call it. A country whose leader turned the full force of the government he controls against its own elections, his political opponents and congressional leaders would not be considered a normal democracy.

It would be described as a democracy in crisis. If it had a robust constitution, it would be called a constitutional crisis. We should be willing to say the same about our own.

Calling this crisis what it is will allow us to do something about it. It will empower the courts to protect democracy. It will encourage Congress to assert its power, conduct oversight over the administration and enact needed reforms. 

Most importantly, recognizing that we are in a constitutional crisis will allow us to fully and finally commit to defeating the threat Trump has posed over the last decade, and the threat his movement poses in the years ahead.